Friday, December 25, 2020 T 1350/09 - Different ornaments is inventive, merely unique sensorial signals are not

Using different ornaments can be inventive

Merry  Christmas from the DeltaPatents blogging team.  This decision shows that adding pretty ornament can be inventive even if providing a unique sensorial signal is not.

Claim 1 of the main requests in this opposition was:

1. A display pack comprising a see-through container which contains a plurality of unit-doses of a detergent product in a multiplicity of sensorially distinctive groups, and wherein the groups are distinctive in terms of colour, shape, size, pattern or ornament, or wherein the groups are distinctive in terms of providing a unique sensorial signal such as smell, sound, feel, etc."

The first auxiliary request struck the  final wherein clause : " or wherein the groups are distinctive in terms of providing a unique sensorial signal such as smell, sound, feel, etc." That made the difference.